Citrus Heights Sentinel Logo

Articles:

Mother, daughter, in Citrus Heights, accused of dismemberment of father

A mother (left) and daughter (right) were arrested Nov. 17 in Citrus Heights on suspicion of murder. // Placer County Sheriff's Office
A mother (left) and daughter (right) were arrested Nov. 17 in Citrus Heights on suspicion of murder. // Placer County Sheriff’s Office

By Sara Beth Williams–
Placer County officials have formally accused a mother and daughter who were living in Citrus Heights of dismembering their husband and father, Paul Fitzmaurice Jr., separating his body parts, and dumping them somewhere in the forests of the Placer County foothills, according to court documents filed on Nov. 19.

The wife of Paul, 75-year-old Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, and their daughter, 45-year-old Mary Fitzmaurice, lived at a residence on Lichen Drive in Citrus Heights, where officials say they told family members for at least four years that their husband and father was still alive and living with them.

Court documents show Mary Fitzmaurice has been charged with murder, and her mother is accused of accessory to murder. As well, officials allege the mother helped dismember the body into six pieces and helped dispose of the body. Only the head of the victim has been discovered to date.

Gwenn Fitzmaurice is also charged with grand theft of property because she was receiving Paul’s pension and Social Security payments after his death, from 2022 to 2026.

Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo announced Wednesday during a press conference that the two had been arrested Tuesday, Nov. 17 in Citrus Heights, on suspicion of murder. Paul’s severed head was found in 2022 in a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill in Placer County but he was not identified until 2024. No other remains of the victim’s body have been found.

A portion of Lichen Drive in Citrus Heights was closed for most of Tuesday as Placer County Sheriff’s deputies carried out a search warrant at a single-family residence on the neighborhood street. The search was conducted to gather evidence in the case. No remains of the body were found at the Lichen Drive residence.

An FBI Evidence Response Team was also deployed to assist in the search of the house on Tuesday, the FBI Sacramento Field Office confirmed.

Because the investigation is still ongoing, Woo and Placer County’s District Attorney say a motive for murder was unknown at this time.

“They found the severed head in a state of decomposition, and at the time detectives were not able to identify [the victim],” Woo said, adding that it took two years for the detectives to finally identify the decedent. In January 2024, after utilizing a private lab, a “potential distant relative was possibly identified,” Woo said.

FBI detectives assisted in the case and traveled out of state to interview and obtain DNA from a potential relative. This allowed the detectives to identify the victim as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., who was 73 at the time of his death.

Through further investigation, detectives discovered that the victim had never been reported missing and was reportedly still living at the address on Lichen Drive.

Fitzmaurice was estranged from some of his blood relatives, and after talking with other family members, officials say those relatives were told by the mother and daughter that he was still alive but reclusive and suffered from substance abuse. The living relatives filed for and were granted a protective order on Thursday.

Woo thanked multiple regional partners for their collaboration throughout the case investigation, including the FBI, Citrus Heights Police Department, and the Placer County Cold Case Foundation, a nonprofit formed by community leaders that helps fundraise for expensive DNA testing.

Woo said the foundation helped to fund DNA testing evidence that has brought this case to a conclusion.

The case is still an active investigation, Placer County says, adding that there is no risk to the public.

Have a news tip?  Let us know here.

Quality local news needs your support. Subscribe to the Citrus Heights Sentinel today! Click here to subscribe.